Ceriwis - [CPU]Gaming Performance: Intel i3 2100 vs Phenom II X4 B55

[CPU]Gaming Performance: Intel i3 2100 vs Phenom II X4 B55
Langsung aja y agan2 yang terhormat http://static.kaskus.us/images/smilies/sumbangan/07.gif
Mau coba kasih review i3 2100 vs phenom B55 OC
Ane sempet baca2 banyak yang ragu pilih i3 2100 ato phenom 955BE buat ngegame
Nah disini ane kasi sedikit review GAMING PERFORMANCE dua procie diatas, plus versus 955be di OC ke 3,6ghz 
Untuk mempertipis marjin harga, i3 2100 ditest menggunakan mobo chipset H61 (bilang aja kantong tipis http://static.kaskus.us/images/smilies/sumbangan/8.gif )

Rig

Spoiler for :
AMD Phenom II X4 B55 @3,2 & 3,6 ghz
Biostar TA890GXB-HD

versus
Spoiler for :
Intel I3 2100
Asrock H61M-U3S3

G.skill 4GBXL 10666
Sapphire 6870 non reference OC 1,025ghz/4748 @ 1,2v (berusaha sedikit terlalu keras buat nyaingin 6950 http://static.kaskus.us/images/smilies/sumbangan/8.gif)
Amacrox free earth 550w
Monitor 20' @1600x900
Catalyst 11.1a

[FYI, ane pakai Phenom B55 untuk "mensimulasikan" performa Phenom 955BE. Sudah dicek di thread AMD Lounge klo performa dua procie ini sama http://static.kaskus.us/images/smili...bangan/q03.gif)

Benchmark

Phenom II X4 B55 @3,2ghz

Spoiler for 3d mark vantage:
http://img577.imageshack.us/img577/8379/unledxqc.jpg

Spoiler for just cause 2:
http://img853.imageshack.us/img853/9883/b5532.jpg[/IMG]

Spoiler for lost planet 2:
gambarnya ilang http://static.kaskus.us/images/smilies/sumbangan/06.gif tapi ane inget FPS 33,4

Spoiler for dirt 2:
http://img832.imageshack.us/img832/3...0606214629.jpg

Spoiler for crysis warhead:
http://img192.imageshack.us/img192/7526/crysisc.jpg

Spoiler for unigine heaven:
http://img834.imageshack.us/img834/3...0622045833.jpg

Phenom II X4 B55 @ 3,6 ghz

Spoiler for 3d mark vantage:
http://img560.imageshack.us/img560/3225/vantaget.jpg

Spoiler for just cause 2:
http://img710.imageshack.us/img710/6...e201106072.jpg

Spoiler for lost planet 2:
http://img685.imageshack.us/img685/2...0723302500.jpg

Spoiler for dirt 2:
http://img194.imageshack.us/img194/7...0607233358.jpg

Spoiler for crysis warhead:
http://img689.imageshack.us/img689/5879/unledka.jpg

Spoiler for unigine heaven:
http://img709.imageshack.us/img709/1...0723204561.jpg

Intel I3 2100

Spoiler for 3d mark vantage:
http://img685.imageshack.us/img685/9196/unledaw.jpg

Spoiler for just cause 2:
http://img837.imageshack.us/img837/5...e201106112.jpg [/IMG]

Spoiler for lost planet 2:
http://img339.imageshack.us/img339/3...1200110782.jpg

Spoiler for dirt 2:
http://img808.imageshack.us/img808/3...0612001548.jpg

Spoiler for crysis warhead:
http://img696.imageshack.us/img696/2923/53417831.jpg

Spoiler for unigine heaven:
http://img7.imageshack.us/img7/8474/...1200404799.jpg

Grafik Average FPS (+3D Mark Vantage dalam ribuan)

Spoiler for :
http://img812.imageshack.us/img812/4844/unleduvv.jpg

Dapat dilihat, dari game dan benchmark tools yang digunakan untuk test, i3 2100 bisa lead dengan Phenom II B55 OC meskipun menggunakan chipset H61 http://static.kaskus.us/images/smili...bangan/q03.gif

==========================

Okelah, langsung kesimpulan ya http://static.kaskus.us/images/smilies/sumbangan/14.gif

Intel i3 2100
Pros
Harga lebih murah 100rbuan daripada Phenom 955
Performa sedikit lebih baik daripada Phenom 955 be
TDP lebih rendah daripada phenom 955 (65 watt)
Pake mobo H61 pun, masi bisa upgrade sampe i7 2600 http://static.kaskus.us/images/smili...bangan/001.gif

Cons
Bukan quadcore murni
Overclock sgt minim
Harga mobo buat yang versi H67/P67 masih cenderung mahal

Reccomended for:
Punya dana minim, tapi pengen suatu saat bisa upgrade http://static.kaskus.us/images/smilies/sumbangan/47.gif
Murni buat game
Pengen procie bertenaga tapi sedang cinta dengan segala sesuatu yang berbau hemat listrik (Go greeeeeeen http://static.kaskus.us/images/smili...bangan/q03.gif )

Phenom II X4 B55/955BE
Pros
Quadcore murni
Overclock tinggi dengan unlock multiplier

Cons
TDP tinggi (125 watt)
Chipset 8xx Mulai akan tergantikan

Reccomended for:
Butuh multitasking/render2 yang butuh banyak core http://static.kaskus.us/images/smili...bangan/q03.gif
Berminat main overclock http://static.kaskus.us/images/smili...bangan/001.gif